In a move drawing global attention, US President Donald Trump has announced an end to all future funding for South Africa, citing concerns over the country’s land expropriation policies.
This decision, which comes a week after Trump ordered a stop-work for all global health funding, including PEPFAR, has sparked debates on international diplomacy, human rights, and economic stability.
Trump’s position on South Africa’s land reform
Last month, President Ramaphosa signed a bill that allows the South African government to offer “nil compensation” in certain circumstances for land expropriated in the public interest. The legislation applies to cases where land is abandoned, held purely for speculation, or where offering no compensation is deemed “just and equitable.”
The law aims to address historical injustices stemming from apartheid by redistributing land to redress racial and economic imbalances. However, it has drawn criticism from some international figures, including Trump and Musk, who argue that it could lead to human rights violations.
Ramaphosa’s diplomatic response
Ramaphosa, despite previous optimism about US-South Africa relations, responded with a call for dialogue, while also addressing what many South Africans view as misinformation. “The South African government has not confiscated any land,” he shared on X. ” The recently adopted Expropriation Act is not a confiscation instrument, but a constitutionally mandated legal process that ensures public access to land in an equitable and just manner as guided by the constitution.”
He added: “South Africa, like the United States of America and other countries, has always had expropriation laws that balance the need for public usage of land and the protection of rights of property owners.”
He clarified that US aid, apart from the PEPFAR program does not significantly impact the country’s financial stability. “Except for PEPFAR aid, which constitutes 17% of South Africa’s HIV/AIDS programme, there was no other significant funding provided by the United States.”
However, Ramaphosa signaled South Africa’s willingness to engage with the US regarding the broader implications of land reform. “We look forward to engaging with the Trump administration over our land reform policy and issues of bilateral interest. We are certain that out of those engagements, we will share a better and common understanding over these matters,” he said
International reactions
Trump’s decision has sparked mixed reactions globally. Some critics argue that using foreign aid as leverage over another country’s policies is an overreach, while others view it as a firm stance on property rights and human rights violations.
Adding to the controversy, South African-born entrepreneur and Trump close Trump ally Elon Musk, now serving as the US head of Government Efficiency (established by the White House to implement the President’s DOGE Agenda), voiced strong opposition to South Africa’s land policies.
He warned they could lead to a “genocide of white people,” further intensifying debates on the issue. It didn’t just stop there, in his direct response to Ramaphosa, Musk subposted his post on X, as shared below, asking the South African head of state, “why do you have openly racist ownership laws?”
Economic & diplomatic consequences
While the US financial aid to South Africa is relatively small, the symbolic impact of Trump’s move could influence international investors and diplomatic relations. The withdrawal of the US support may push South Africa to strengthen ties with other economic partners, such as China and other African nations.
For Trump, this aligns with his broader strategy of leveraging economic power in diplomatic disputes, as seen in his dealings with China, Mexico, and Canada. For Ramaphosa, this presents a test of economic resilience and diplomatic strategy.
As the world watches, South Africa faces a pivotal moment: Will it negotiate with the US or pivot towards alternative global allies? The outcome of this diplomatic standoff may set a precedent for handling similar disputes worldwide.
*Stay informed with the latest developments and inspiring stories from South Africa. Follow NOWinSA for more South African Brand News and Inspiring Stories.
