Marumo Gallants player Thapelo Dhludhlu is at the centre of a growing police investigation after authorities said they believe his alleged kidnapping may have been staged, prompting Sports Minister Gayton McKenzie to condemn what he called a waste of state resources.
The development comes as Minister McKenzie publicly defended police findings and rejected calls to keep the matter out of the public eye.
Mpumalanga police are investigating the 27-year-old midfielder after his family reported that he had allegedly been kidnapped. They claimed an unknown caller used Dhludhlu’s cellphone to demand R50,000 for his release.
Detectives immediately opened a kidnapping-for-ransom case and launched an urgent search.
The footballer returned home unharmed later that day.
Investigators now say there is no evidence that any ransom was paid. They believe the alleged kidnapping may never have happened and are considering charges that include defeating the ends of justice.
Police investigate alleged staged kidnapping
Mpumalanga police spokesperson Mavela Masondo confirmed investigators uncovered information which changed the direction of the case.
“The player returned home unharmed. Follow-up investigations indicated that no ransom was ever paid as alleged and the apparent kidnapping might never have happened. Investigations continue.”
The case drew national attention after supporters, football clubs and members of the public shared missing-person posters and appeals across social media.
Police have not announced whether additional charges may follow once the investigation is complete.
McKenzie says state resources were wasted
McKenzie said police informed him that investigators had found no kidnapping had taken place.
“I wanna thank the Acting Minister of Police Firoz Cachalia and Captain Moloko and his team for investigating and uncovering that no kidnapping has happened here. The player apparently owed a lot of people money and was in hiding.”
His comments quickly sparked debate online.
Some criticised the minister for discussing the matter publicly.
McKenzie rejected that criticism.
“Do you have the slightest idea of the resources invested to investigate this matter? Do you know the damage this has caused internationally? We have never been known as a country where players get kidnapped. I merely quoted the police statement. This nonsense cannot be sanitised.”
He later added:
“We will be told people are missing, ppl will be rallied to help with the search, prayers will go out, police will be involved, posters & flyers will be made and distributed, only for the person to appear and asking for privacy. I don’t play that game, I say what happened.”
McKenzie also thanked Acting Police Minister Firoz Cachalia for the SAPS investigation, saying officers had worked quickly to establish the facts.
SAFPU urges restraint as investigation continues
Before police disclosed their latest findings, the South African Football Players Union (SAFPU) appealed for patience and privacy.
“The circumstances surrounding Thapelo’s disappearance remain a private matter at this stage as discussed with the family. We therefore respectfully appeal to the public, the media and the broader football community to afford him and his family the dignity, privacy and space they require while the relevant authorities continue with their work.”
The union also thanked South Africans for their support.
It urged the public to avoid speculation while authorities completed their investigation.
What charges could Thapelo Dhludhlu face?
Police are considering a charge of defeating the ends of justice.
Deliberately making or supporting a false crime report can divert police resources, delay genuine investigations and expose those involved to criminal prosecution.
South Africa’s common law offence of defeating the ends of justice, together with provisions of the Cybercrimes Act, 2020, may apply where electronic communications form part of an alleged offence, depending on the evidence gathered by investigators.
The offence carries no prescribed minimum or maximum sentence. Courts instead impose penalties based on the facts of each case. Recent South African judgments have seen convictions for defeating the ends of justice attract sentences ranging from 12 months’ imprisonment to several years behind bars, depending on the seriousness of the conduct and its impact, as illustrated in a previous Western Cape High Court judgment.
The case has also reignited debate about the impact of false crime reports on already stretched policing resources and public confidence in missing-person investigations.
ALSO READ: Cultural diplomacy or waste? Debate heats up over World Cup artist delegation, after McKenzie defended plans to send South African artists to the 2026 FIFA World Cup amid criticism over spending priorities.
For trending South African sports news that matters most, visit the NOWinSA Sports NewsDesk regularly.
